| 8/28/2012 | L, 1-4 | West Virginia Tech | Circleville, OH | 0-1 |
| 8/31/2012 | L, 0-2 | Union College | Georgetown, KY | 0-2 |
| 9/1/2012 | W, 2-1 | Georgetown College | Georgetown, KY | 1-2 |
| 9/6/2012 | L, 0-2 | Otterbein University | Westerville, OH | 1-3 |
| 9/13/2012 | W, 5-0 | Kentucky Christian University | Circleville, OH | 2-3 1-0 |
| 9/19/2012 | L, 2-0 | Mount Vernon Nazarene University | Mount Vernon, OH | 2-4 1-0 |
| 9/21/2012 | L, 4-3 | #1 Moody Bible Institute | Circleville, OH | 2-5 1-0 |
| 9/25/2012 | W, 4-0 | Appalachian Bible College | Circleville, OH | 3-5 2-0 |
| 9/29/2012 | W, 3-1 | Johnson University | Circleville, OH | 4-5 3-0 |
| 10/4/2012 | W, 4-3 | Berea College | Berea, KY | 5-5 3-0 |
| 10/6/2012 | W, 4-0 | #10 Crown College (Homecoming) | Circleville, OH | 6-5 4-0 |
| 10/9/2012 | L, 1-3 | Asbury University | Circleville, OH | 6-6 4-0 |
| 10/10/2012 | W, 7-0 | Kentucky Christian University | Grayson, KY | 7-6 5-0 |
| 10/13/2012 | L, 1-6 | #2 Northland International University | Grand Rapids, MI | 7-7 5-0 |
| 10/16/2012 | W, 5-0 | Appalachian Bible College | Mount Hope, WV | 8-7 6-0 |
| 10/19/2012 | L, 0-1 | Johnson University | Knoxville, TN | 8-8 6-1 |
| 10/20/2012 | W, 4-0 | Crown College | Powell, TN | 9-8 7-1 |
| 10/22/2012 | T, 3-3 | Toccoa Falls College | Circleville, OH | 9-8-1 7-1 |
| 10/26/2012 | W, 1-0 | Regional Semifinal vs Johnson | Grayson, KY | 10-8-1 |
| 10/27/2012 | W, 5-1 | Regional Championship vs Appalachian | Grayson, KY | 11-8-1 |
| 11/7/2012 | T, 0-0 (W,4-2 PK) | National Quarterfinals vs #3 Providence | Kissimmee, FL | 11-8-2 |
| 11/8/2012 | L, 8-0 | National Semifinal vs #2 Northland | Kissimmee, FL | 11-9-1 |
| 11/10/2012 | T, 1-1 (L, 0-3 PK) | Nationals vs #4 Manhattan | Kissimmee, FL | 11-9-3 |
